rock’s stars not larger than life (or: stage height, classic hero shot lead to unreal expectations)
Friday, October 31st, 2003One of my co-workers commented to me the other day that the man to whom I had just served coffee looked an awful lot like Eddie Vedder.
“No way,” I said. “That guy’s at least 6 feet 3; Eddie is maybe 5 feet 7 on a good day.” (Yes, it’s true; I know how tall he is.)
She was taken aback by this and asked several times if I was sure that Vedder could be that short.
In short, she couldn’t believe that it was possible for a rock star to be so small.
Even current rock stars have the same memories from the days when they were the ones paying to get into clubs.
Vedder himself had this problem when he was younger, and mentioned it when he inducted the Ramones into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame last year.
“Before the show even started, I was trying to get closer and closer and got up to the stage,” he mumbled during the rambling, 17-minute speech. “As I was getting closer I saw something really strange about the microphone stand in the middle. It was about 10 feet high. … I thought, ‘Who the f*** is going to sing at that microphone stand?’”
So what is it that makes these on-stage personas appear larger than life?
After much consideration, I point the blame squarely at the stage itself.
First off, if you go see any big-name arena rock band (say, Pearl Jam or R.E.M.), you’re most likely not going to be anywhere near the stage, and thus the people standing on it will seem quite small. Now, this may seem counterintuitive to my reasoning, but consider what you hear at such a show. The band is far away and tiny but at the same time earsplittingly loud.
This is obviously the work of amps no normal person could ever afford and some really, really big speakers. But if you let yourself get lost in the music, it just might seem like magic.
Oh, and those giant projection screens, too — Michael Stipe seems less diminutive after you’ve seen his head 15 feet tall.
Then there are those concerts at much smaller venues, places that trade off thousands of people’s worth of audience for a much more intimate feel.
The larger of these clubs usually have a decently tall stage — maybe four feet — and a barricade to put a couple of feet, along with a bald security guard, between you and the band’s shoes. So if you’re like me and always as close to the action as possible, a good portion of the night is spent neck craned up.
This results in everyone on the stage being bestowed with the classic hero shot, quite possibly the most flattering and grandeur-inspiring view of a person this side of Michelangelo’s “David” (think Citizen Kane at the lectern). Plus there’s that added end-of-the-night bonus feature of feeling like you showed up late to the movie theater and were stuck with lousy front row seats.
Then you have those small clubs that lack the funds for metal fences and an extra foot or two of stage height.
The performers at these shows are most likely a little more obscure, a little more accessible as real people, and yet you are still forced to look upward to watch them. It may not be as bad as with those other bands, but there’s still something about the height difference that places them on an entirely different importance level.
I was privileged enough to see Beulah in Philadelphia a couple of weeks ago. The show was at the quirkiest venue I’ve ever seen a band play at — the romp room (rec room or what-have-you) of a church. The “stage” was simply the area of the floor between all of the speakers; the bands were forced to play at the same level as their fans.
This was interesting to observe during the first opening band’s set, as everyone seemed content to sit on the floor and get the same old neck-ruining view.
Unfortunately for Matt Suggs and company, the hero shot was to no avail. Their songs just weren’t much good. And, as my friend Kristen so aptly put it, Suggs was a slovenly Stephen King look-alike and his guitarist resembled a “pretentious English teacher standing on an amp.”
The crowd was standing by the time Beulah took over, which brought about a new and unnerving situation. Kristen and I were front and center, as per usual, and I wasn’t exactly sure where to look. It was uncomfortable to be at eye level with, maybe even looking down a couple of inches at a rock star. So I just kind of glanced around the room nervously.
Singer Miles Kurosky was intrigued by the room’s setup and told us that we were allowed to step over the invisible line separating the band from the masses.
Not surprisingly, everyone stayed put. Well, save for the obligatory kid who put one foot on the previously forbidden side of a tangle of wires and waved his hands around in that “Look at me! I’m a rebel!” manner we all know and hate.
I can’t condone rock star glorification. Just because they appear to be seven feet tall doesn’t mean that they have super powers. They’re just normal people with the amazing (or not-so-amazing, depending on the band) ability to create music. Put them on a pedestal if you must, but they’re still prone to all of the same mistakes and shortcomings as the rest of us.
On that note, I’d like to mention singer-songwriter Elliott Smith’s recent suicide. He battled alcoholism, heroin addiction and depression to create some of the most gorgeous, intimate music of the past decade and now he’s gone. So remember, a knife to chest and the motivation behind it shed the same blood, whether it be a famous musician’s or yours or mine.