I spent a good chunk of my Thanksgiving Break sprawled on an uncomfortable couch, limbs akimbo, watching VH1’s “I Love the 80s: Strikes Back.” There’s a certain kind of torpor that comes with being stuck on an empty campus for a five-day weekend; I couldn’t bring myself to move.
The marathon of nostalgia not only entertained but also got me to thinking about why, exactly, a 10-year period is the grounds for classifying pretty much anything in a society that still can’t accept the metric system.
The Pixies are one of the most prominent victims of this as far as the music world is concerned. Anyone familiar with their work will tell you they were one of the best bands of their era — but what exactly does that mean?
Black Francis and company released four studio albums in their short career, one per year from 1988 to 1991. That’s two albums in each decade, but we’re only allowed to classify them as an ’80s band or a ’90s band. Usually this requires too much thinking and the Pixies fall by the wayside.
On a smaller scale, why is the calendar year the basis for so many lists? The Gregorian calendar was implemented to simplify the calculation of Easter’s date, not as a means of rating music over time. The albums from the first half of any given year might not be on the same playing field as those from the second half, or vice versa.
Fortunately for you (unfortunately for me), society dictates that I’d be an impotent music columnist if I didn’t provide a list of the year’s sine qua nons, so I will. There are some ground rules, however.
As hard as it is to compare music across long periods of time, it’s equally difficult to weigh against one another the different mediums it can be released on, so this is a list of full-length studio albums only — no EPs, no greatest hits or other types of compilations, no live albums, no soundtracks and, apologies to Neil Young and Elvis Costello, no reissues.
And, given my limited knowledge/funds, this list is as subjective as it gets; I can only rank albums I’ve listened to thoroughly. So, much as I enjoyed the few songs I heard by The Decemberists, The Shins and The Postal Service, they won’t be included. I couldn’t even find much-lauded records by British Sea Power and The Hidden Cameras. And, let’s face it, there just wasn’t enough time to fully digest Britney Spears’ latest. Here goes:
10. (tie) Rufus Wainwright, “Want One” — Wainwright warbles; critics rejoice. It’s not a bad formula. The only adjective I could invent to describe this one was “Rufus-y.”
10. (tie) Damien Rice, “O” — It was happenstance that I became cognizant of this guy — one track on a mix CD from an acquaintance, you know the drill. In any case, Rice has a great set of vocal cords and broguishly troubadours his way to a convincing debut.
9. The Minus 5, “Down with Wilco” — Wilco’s a great band, as is R.E.M., so putting all of the former and half of the latter into a blender that spits out CDs should yield pretty decent results. This side project collaboration, a self-proclaimed “tragedy in three halfs,” is a low-key masterpiece — certainly not a “Yankee Hotel Foxtrot” or a “Murmur,” but who could expect that?
8. Fountains of Wayne, “Welcome Interstate Managers” — I would probably classify the Fountains as just another power pop band after one listen of any of their albums, but a closer look reveals that their songwriting belies that categorization. “Stacy’s Mom” may have been this summer’s big hit, but you might be surprised by the charming “Valley Winter Song” and the kitschy, alt-country “Hung Up on You.”
7. Ben Harper, “Diamonds on the Inside” — This is Ben Harper’s weakest album. That said, it’s a fantastic, although unfocused, piece of work. In just the first six tracks, Harper touches upon reggae, pedal steel blues, Cat Stevens-ish folk, Hendrix-inspired rock, soul and funk.
6. Kings of Leon, “Youth and Young Manhood” — The Kings of Leon set the bar high with their impressive debut EP, “Holy Roller Novocaine,” and their first full-length album goes out of its way to attest that it wasn’t just beginner’s luck.
5. Guster, “Keep It Together” — The members of Guster prove that they aren’t one-trick, acoustic-guitar-and-bongo ponies with “Keep It Together” by introducing a bass guitar, drumsticks and even a banjo to the mix. There are a few misfires, but “Amsterdam” and “Careful” contain some of the best hooks this side of a Bass Pro Shop.
4. Radiohead, “Hail to the Thief” — The band that took the guitar away from rock ‘n’ roll brought it back, sort of. This was supposed to be a return to the days of “The Bends,” but ended up somewhere between “OK Computer” and “Kid A.” That is to say: it’s in very good company.
3. Belle & Sebastian, “Dear Catastrophe Waitress” — The quixotic Scottish something-tet have released their most accessible album to date, a veritable indie pop magnum opus. Stuart Murdoch hasn’t lost his ability to write great lyrics, nor his nifty accent.
2. The White Stripes, “Elephant” — In March, this album was surrounded by a sea of hype. While it may not quite have lived up to the standard set by “White Blood Cells” and “De Stijl,” “Elephant” is straightforward bluesy garage rock worthy of all the accolades it has received.
1½. OutKast, “Speakerboxxx/The Love Below” — This can’t be my favorite album of 2003, considering I’ve only heard five 30-second snippets of it, but every pretentious year-end top album list needs an unexpected genre in a high position. I don’t doubt, however, that Big Boi and Andre 3000 have put together a solid record, and the catchiness of “Hey Ya” alone has made me want to dance to the nearest store and pick this up.
1. Beulah, “Yoko” — This is so good. Do yourself a favor and buy it. Right now.